Student perspectives on self directed learning carolinda douglass1 and sherrill r. Another leading critical pedagogy theorist who freire called his intellectual cousin, peter mclaren, wrote the foreword. Humanist learning theory 2 introduction in this paper, i will present the humanist learning theory. Selfdirected learning or an emancipatory practice of adult education. The author considers the conceptual soundness of selfdirected learning and elaborates a definition of the term. Self directed learning and critical thinking are both worthwhile frameworks. Habermas is presented as a learning theory positing three generic domains of.
Selfdirected learning, political clarity, and the critical practice of adult education. Ill discuss the key principles of this theory, what attracted me to this theory, the roles of the learners and the instructor, and ill finish with three examples of how this learning theory. A brief comprehensive analysis selfdirection in adult learning has been a topic of increasing interest and investigation by scholars and practitioners of. Now in its fourth edition, this comprehensive volume is fully revised to reflect the latest developments in theory, research, and practice. Self directed learning no matter how good teaching may be, each student must take the responsibility for his own education presented by. I teach my students that failure is an opportunity for growth and that they shouldnt be afraid to try new things, but sometimes its hard to take my own advice. Adult learning theories 2011 page 2 tive, without the help of others in planning, carrying out, and evaluating their own learning experiences knowles, 1975. A selfdirected learning model for critical literacy. Selfdirected learning columbia center for teaching and learning.
An analysis of two dominant theoretical frameworks critical thinking and self directed learning shows that responsibility and control are fundamental to both. When a job requires proficiency in manual or highly technical skills with. The four stages of the selfdirected learning model. Selfdirected learning sdl is an education strategy wherein students, overseen by the lecturer, decide upon their own learning within given parameters and, in so doing, take responsibility for. View enhanced pdf access article on wiley online library html view download pdf for offline viewing. Mclaren and giroux coedited one book on critical pedagogy and coauthored another in the 1990s. Most of the concepts emphasis has been on the external control and management of. To critical theorists such as griffin 1983, 1987 and collins 1991, however, the predominance of the concept of selfdirected learning illustrates a disturbing tendency in a field that elevates practical competence above theoretical sophistication and political understanding. Critical perspectives on a the ory in progress the contribution of transformative learning theory to the springer link learning as transformation. Odonnells critical theory of selves directed learning has as its pur pose the emancipation of individuals from.
Self directed learning is a type of instructional strategy where students take charge of their learning process. Selfdirected learning is a type of instructional strategy where students take charge of their learning process. This does not mean that self directed learning is highly individualized learning always conducted in isolation. A critical theory of selfadirected learning wiley online library. Jack mezirow is professor of adult and continuing education and director, center for adult education, at teachers college, columbia university, new york city. Habermas, critical theory and selvesdirected learning by. Toward a critical theory of education1 douglas kellner. Apr 05, 2018 selfdirected learning destabilizes traditional models of learning and that can be scary. To critical theorists such as griffin 1983, 1987 and collins 1991, however, the predominance of the concept of self directed learning illustrates a disturbing tendency in a field that elevates practical competence above theoretical sophistication and political understanding. Selfdirected learning and critical thinking are both worthwhile frameworks. Separate studies have been conducted on these two issues, but a few ones are devoted to the relationship between them in other countries or even in iran. For nearly three decades, learning in adulthood has been the definitive guide in the field of adult education.
He considers social settings, learning styles, independence, middle class lifestyles, and methods of investigation. Selfdirected learning suggests that learners need to be in control of their learning. This article argues that self directed learning should be viewed not as the application of a particular technique but as the capacity of adults for critical self reflection and for changing their lives. Selfdirected learning among thai nurses in clinical practice. The college defines self directed learning for reces as. Brookfield 2003 called the theory culture blind, stating that the concept of selfdirected learning and the concept of the students establishing a nonthreatening relationship with the teacher as facilitator of learning may neglect races and cultures that value the teacher as. The critical theory of jurgen habermas dan macisaac. Effectively supporting selfdirected learning is one of the critical challenges in. A brief comprehensive analysis selfdirection in adult learning has been a topic of increasing interest and investigation by scholars and practitioners of adult education since the mid 1900s. How unschoolers control their education kerry mcdonald duration. The aim of this paper is to introduce a correction into the notion of selfdirected adult learning by way of conjoining it with philosophically elaborated notions of autonomy, selfreflectiveness, and maturity. The recognition that selfdirected learning has a number of different facets and that conceptions differ with which aspect is studied. Perspective transformation is seen as one of the learning domains and the domain most uniquely adult.
Applying an andragogical approach to foster lifelong self. Because university faculty foster critical thinking in students through collaboration and mentoring sanders, 2006, academicians have the opportunity to support students on a lifelong. The relationship between selfdirected learning and critical. Sowath rana, alexandre ardichvili and daiane polesello, promoting self directed learning in a learning organization. The concept of selfdirected learning and its implications for human resource development. Undergraduate student perspectives regarding specific factors associated with self directed learning were collected through eight focus groups.
The concept of selfdirected learning and its implications. The preface explains what is meant by critical practice of sdl, describes educational streams that have fed into the concept, and situates the context within which the ideas about critical sdl developed. Theories on how adults learn such as andragogy knowles, 1980, transformational mezirow, 2000 and self directed learning tough, 1971 and cross, 1981 provide insight into how adult students learn and how instructors like me can be more responsive to the needs of my learners by use of effective teaching practices. Although the concept of selfdirected learning sdl has a rich history of research and practice in the adult education field, it has not received considerable attention in the context of hrd. The book contains a balance of theory and practical suggestions. By being mindful of the ways self directed learning can appear in the classroom, and leveraging it as an integral part of how we learn, we can create a more meaningful learning experience for students that will last beyond the regurgitation of memorized content. A reasonable conceptualization of either framework must involve learners assuming responsibility for meaning while sharing control of the educational process.
By being mindful of the ways selfdirected learning can appear in the classroom, and leveraging it as an integral part of how we learn, we can create a more meaningful learning experience for students that will last beyond the regurgitation of memorized content. It is intended to function as a guide for studentslikely with the support and facilitation of teachers, parents, and mentorsto help students become expert learners. A conceptual model for understanding selfdirected learning. The four stagesvery similar to the gradual release of responsibility modelappear below. A critical theory of adult learning and education sage journals. Research, scholarship, and interest in selfdirected learning has literally exploded. This does not mean that selfdirected learning is highly individualized learning always conducted in isolation. As a philosopher and sociologist he has mastered and creatively articulated an extraordinary range of specialized literature in the social sciences, social theory and the history of ideas in the. Why selfdirected learning is important for struggling.
According to the constructivist theory of learning, students build their own understanding. Emphasis on self directed learning is the reason learning plans and portfolios have gained traction in recent years. The relationship of selfdirected learning readiness to knowledgebased and performancebased measures of success in thirdyear medical. Proceedings of the 29th annual adult education research conference pp. The purpose of this article is to present various findings on self directed learning sdl. Critical theory adopts a hegelian concept of theory by developing holistic theories that attempt to conceptualize the totality of a given field, but that importantly make connections and articulate contradictions, overcoming idealist or reductive theories of the whole. Sdl encourages individuals to become responsible for their own learning, identify gaps in their knowledge gaps and critically appraise new information. Selfdirected learning is most commonly attributed to knowles, because it is one of the assumptions inherent in andragogy. Instructors are urged to provide explicit instruction in critical thinking, to teach how to transfer to new contexts, and to use cooperative or collaborative learning methods and constructivist approaches that place students at the center of the learning process. However, it has also been examined from other points of view separate from knowless theory. International journal of selfdirected learning, 82, 1127. The critical theory of jurgen habermas jurgen habermas is widely considered as the most influential thinker in germany over the past decade 197080. The author also raises some questions about the methodological rigor of the studies on which the new academic orthodoxy is based.
Selfdirected learning at ucsf, the medical school has implemented a portfolio process with the explicit goal of encouraging selfdirected learning. The basic premise of this intervention is that in andragogical theorizing, learners selfdirectedness ought not to be thought as obvious and thus beyond question. Habermas concept of communicative rationality, in which reason is construed in terms of the noncoercive intersubjectivity of mutual understanding and reciprocal recognition, provides a valid foundation on which the theory and practice of selvesdirected learning can be developed. The new edition of the authoritative book in the field of adult education fully revised to reflect the latest research and practice implications. A total of 80 upperclassmen provided input revealing three emergent themes in. She makes the case for each of the four and their support of adult learner characteristics, but asserts that there is no one theory that explains all of how adults learn, just as there is no one theory that explains all human learning. Eric ej3257 a critical theory of selfdirected learning. Like reflective practice, self directed learning is one of the building blocks of the cpl program. Self directed learning is a core theoretical construct distinguishing adult education as a field of study. Selfdirected learning is one response, something slideshare user barbara stokes captures in this chart, based on the model by gerald grow. This lesson will discuss components, benefits, and teaching strategies of self. Sowath rana, alexandre ardichvili and daiane polesello, promoting selfdirected learning in a learning organization. Selfdirected learning destabilizes traditional models of learning and that can be scary.
Based on such literature and research, five major findings can be extracted. Brookfield 2003 called the theory culture blind, stating that the concept of selfdirected learning and the concept of the students establishing a nonthreatening relationship with the teacher as facilitator of learning may neglect races and cultures that value the teacher as the primary source of knowledge and direction. Self directed learning is learning in which the conceptualization, design, conduct and evaluation of a learning project are directed by the learner. The above is the latest draft of our selfdirected learning framework, version 1. They simply apply to different domains of the adult education enterprise. A critical theory of adult learning and education jack. Effectively supporting selfdirected learning is one of the critical challenges in supporting lifelong learning. Like reflective practice, selfdirected learning is one of the building blocks of the cpl program. Freire wrote the introduction to his 1988 work, teachers as intellectuals. In fact, some scholars consider sdl critical in distance education settings with its unique characteristic of the physical and social. Theory is needed to improve education, assessment and policy in self directed learning. The college defines selfdirected learning for reces as.
Therefore, the concept can be grouped into four broad categories. The nature and etiology of perspective transformation is elaborated with particular focus on the function of reification and of reflectivity. Sep 05, 20 the book contains a balance of theory and practical suggestions. Faculty of continuing education, university of calgary. Selfdirected learning is a core theoretical construct distinguishing adult education as a field of study. Mezirow, a critical theory of selfdirected learning, new directions for continuing education, n25 1730. Offer more opportunities to develop critical higherorder thinking skills based on a constructive learning approach, ict helps students focus on higherlevel concepts rather than less meaningful tasks levin and wadmany 2006. A self directed learning model for critical literacy by terry heick the above is the latest draft of our self directed learning this model is built around the concept of self knowledgebetter understanding ones self and that to inform ones interactions with the world. Nov 19, 2019 the aim of this paper is to introduce a correction into the notion of selfdirected adult learning by way of conjoining it with philosophically elaborated notions of autonomy, selfreflectiveness, and maturity. Theories on how adults learn such as andragogy knowles, 1980, transformational mezirow, 2000 and selfdirected learning tough, 1971 and cross, 1981 provide insight into how adult students learn and how instructors like me can be more responsive to the needs of. Pdf the ability to acquire skills in self directed learning may be the key link. Ellinger advances in developing human resources 2004 6. Implications of a critical theory for selfdirected learning and adult education are explored. One of the most important tasks of the teacher is to raise student awareness of their roles in learning.
In essence, sdl is an informal process that primarily takes place the classoutside room. Towards a transformative and holistic continuing self. Critical pedagogy is a philosophy of education and social movement that developed and applied concepts from critical theory and related traditions to the field of education and the study of culture advocates of critical pedagogy reject the idea that knowledge is ever politically neutral and argue that teaching is an inherently political act, whether the teacher acknowledges that or not. Abstract becoming critically aware of what has been taken for granted about ones own learning is the key to self. Selfdirected learning, political clarity, and the critical. Educational strategies associated with development of problem. Selfdirected learning is learning in which the conceptualization, design, conduct and evaluation of a learning project are directed by the learner. Critical thinking and selfdirected learning in adult. The relationship between selfdirected learning and. Faculty and student views of using digital tools to enhance selfdirected learning and critical thinking. A conceptual model for understanding sdl in online environments it is generally believed that online learning gives more control of the instruction to the learners garrison, 2003.
988 577 76 1149 519 1012 790 445 1608 1388 1440 110 1199 855 650 736 1423 1212 1035 731 1168 2 1047 390 1144 1667 1032 903 1396 1576 1383 655 261 197 359 769 893 655 310 826 641 1430